The Environmentally Conscious Cat - Food
16 06 2008My absenteeism can be quickly explained - we’ve adopted a baby kitten. Her name is Audrey, she was found when she was but a week old five weeks ago Friday. We decided on the name Audrey as she’s all black, very classy, lighthearted, and destined to be spoiled much like Audrey Hepburn in Breakfast at Tiffany’s . We’ve been bottle feeding her for the past month, and thankfully, she’s reaching the tender age of eating on her own. Being both environmentally conscious and aware of the contaminates of most foods, I decided Audrey wasn’t going to be eating just any cat food, she’s going to be eating as well as the rest of us.
My internet research has turned up three issues with mainstream, supermarket cat foods. Cats are true carnivores and cannot get their nutrition from anything except meat, yet the big names have nothing but meat byproducts, wheat fillers and fat toppings. These same companies employ cruel testing methods–they develop a product for animal lovers by abusing animals. Finally, it’s impossible to be environmentally conscious and happily open up a big can of chemicals, I don’t want them in my cat nor my planet. Undoubtedly, the best idea for her would be to feed her raw, organic meats of course, however the demands of my job and life as well as the price of those meats have made that an almost impossible option. Thus, my search for the ultimate food with the ultimate balance of human grade meats from a reputable company neatly packaged in a can of convenience began. Here were my criteria:
- first 3 ingredients were meat and/or water
- no corn/wheat/gluten ingredients
- minimal non-meat filler ingredients
- human grade meat
- .1% taurine
- 10% crude protein in wet food
- animal friendly testing
- preferred, but did not require organic ingredients
- company did not have any pet food recalls to date (this disqualified Nutro Max)
My favorite brand and the brand Audrey is being raised on is Newman’s Own Organic Pet Food. While this pet food is costly at your neighborhood health store at 1.49 a can (I found it at 1.10 a can at buythecase.net, free shipping, super fast ordering, and no tax), it is made with Bell and Evan’s Organic poultry and human grade fishes. Basically, the cat will be eating better than the rest of the family. I noticed one variety of their cat food does have a lot of vegetables in it, however I intend on avoiding that flavor and sticking to the stuff Audrey can process. Admittedly they do have a bit less taurine in their food than the runner up Wellness, however I intend to supplement that with cat grade frozen, raw meats. Company wise, Newman’s has never had a pet food recall, employs animal-friendly testing, uses organic ingredients, and as a bonus, donates part of their profits to pet charities.
Nutritional Breakdown per their website of the turkey dinner:
- First five ingredients are: Organic Turkey, Sufficient Water for Processing, Chicken, Ocean Whitefish, Brown Rice.
- Grain content: Brown Rice, Oat Bran
- Guaranteed nutritional analysis:
Crude Protein…………….10.0% (min)
Crude Fat…………………..7.0% (min)
Crude Fiber………………..1.0% (max)
Moisture……………………78.0% (max)
Ash………………………….2.0% (max)
Magnesium…………………0.025% (max)
Taurine……………………..0.06% (min)
Scored 9 out of 9 (the extra point because they’re charitable, lost one for taurine)
Another brand of food I considered for Audrey was Wellness. Wellness brand food is available at your local pet store such as Petsmart. They add no gluten, corn, soy or meat products to their food as well as use human graded meat. Nutritionally they scrored a little higher with their turkey dinner than Newman’s with the higher amount of taurine guaranteed, however they do not use organic ingredients. Company wise, there have been no Wellness pet food recalls to date, employ animal-friendly testing, and have a charitable program claled ‘Wellpet’. Another factor you have to consider is price, I did find it for a dollar a can at petfooddirect.com, however shipping is not included and tacks on about another 10 dollars an order. Not bad really if you’re going to order 100 cans or so.
My biggest hesitation with Wellness was that they boast about the vegetables in their foods, however also admit that cats are obligate carnivores thus meaning that cats can’t digest veggies. Pretty much, there’s more filler in this food than in the Newman’s food, which is how Newman’s trumped Wellness. I’m still considering introducing her to this brand on occasion to keep her from becoming too picky.
Nutritional breakdown per their website of the turkey dinner:
- First five ingredients are: Turkey, Chicken Liver, Chicken, Chicken Broth, Carrots
- Grain content: none, though a lot of veggies
- Guaranteed nutritional analysis:
Crude Protein…………….10.0% (min)
Crude Fat…………………..7.0% (min)
Crude Fiber………………..1.0% (max)
Moisture……………………78.0% (max)
Ash………………………….1.95% (max)
Magnesium…………………0.025% (max)
Taurine……………………..0.10% (min)
Scored 9 out of 9 (lost a point for not being organic, gained a point for being charitable).
For one reason or another, I really liked Avoderm when I was first doing my research. Their big claim to cat fame is that they use avocado oil in their food that helps maintain a healthy coat and skin. That’s all well and fine, however I’m not even sure a cat can digest avocado oil. They do not carry a turkey flavor (I like the idea of feeding Audrey tryptophan before bed) but do have a fancy schmancy tuna and crab meat flavor. I had a hard time finding out the testing ethics of this company. They’re not listed as being safe by Iamscruelty.com and the only information I could find was a couple years old. If anyone has any information about this I would very much appreciate it. I also can’t find any information if they use human grade meat or not. The company is charitable though, and has partnered with Susan J. Komen breast cancer foundation, which I find very cool.
Nutritional breakdown per their website of the tuna and crabmeat flavor:
- First five ingredients are: Tuna, Tuna Broth, Crab Meat, Sunflower Oil, Salt
- Grain content: none, though sunflower oil and salt seem a bit high
- Guaranteed nutritional analysis:
Crude Protein…………….10.0% (min)
Crude Fat…………………..2.0% (min)
Crude Fiber………………..1.0% (max)
Moisture……………………82.0% (max)
Ash………………………….3% (max)
Magnesium…………………0.02% (max)
Taurine……………………..0.22% (min)
Scored 7 out of 9 (lost a point for not being organic, skepticism toward animal testing, unsure about human grade meat. Gained a point for being charitable)
I didn’t give Organix a lot of time in research in that nutritionally, they fell low in comparison to the competition. Their canned food is lower in protein and taurine, and chock full of filler vegetables. They’re better than the supermarket brands all the same and I believe I noticed something about charitable work on their website. If they ever do decide to revamp their nutrition, I would definitely consider them.
Nutritional breakdown per their website of the turkey and veggie platter
- First five ingredients: Turkey broth, chicken, turkey, chicken liver, egg white, potato starch
- Grain content: rice flour (lot of fruit and veggies though
- Guaranteed nutritional analysis:
Crude Protein…………….8.5% (min)
Crude Fat…………………..4.5% (min)
Crude Fiber………………..1.5% (max)
Moisture……………………82.0% (max)
Ash………………………….2.2% (max)
Magnesium…………………0.025% (max)
Taurine……………………..0.05% (min)
Score: 4 or 5, most points lost for nutrition
Halo brand pet food has received a bit of press lately given they’re being sponsored by Ellen DeGeneres. I totally dig that, however that doesn’t mean diddly in terms of it being good for your cat. Their website claims to take a holistic approach to formulating their foods, which intrigued me. Further research revealed they use whole meat and no by products, but there’s no mention of animal grade meats. Nutritionally they fell short in comparison to the competition as well. Halo does have a good reputation for ethical testing, but again, the most important thing in my research was nutrition. Here’s the analysis of the turkey recipe per their website:
- First five ingredients: Turkey, beef liver, broth, green peas, yellow squash
- No grain additives, though full of vegetables
- No added taurine!
- Guaranteed nutritional analysis:
Crude Protein…………….5.4% (min)
Crude Fat…………………..2.3% (min)
Crude Fiber………………..4.3% (max)
Moisture……………………85.0% (max)
Ash………………………….unknown
Magnesium…………………unknown
Taurine……………………..unknown
Score: 5 out of 9 (points lost for nutrition)
So yes, there are a lot of factors to consider when choosing your pet’s food. No canned food is perfect unfortunately, and we as owners have to make that decision. In Audrey’s case I decided an organic human grade poultry was more important than the .05% taurine that Newman’s was lacking as I can supplement that with raw foods. All the same, I hope this guide will help you in the difficult decisions of your cat’s dietary future
Comments : No Comments »
Tags : cat food, halo, newman's, organic, organic cat food, taurine, wellness
Categories : Enviro Cat, Product Review
